Reverse Wine Snob

Wine doesn't have to be expensive to be good

  • About
  • Aldi® Picks
  • Costco® Picks
  • Trader Joe’s® Picks
  • FREE GUIDE
  • Insider Deals
menu icon
go to homepage
Get Our Free Guide!
search icon
Homepage link
  • FREE GUIDE!
  • Insider Deals
  • Best Of Lists
    • - Costco
    • - Trader Joe's
    • - Aldi
  • About
  • The Rating System
  • More Helpful Links
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Twitter
  • ×

    Kirkland Signature Rutherford Napa Valley Meritage 2009 - Costco Delivers Another Knockout

    By: Jon Thorsen Published: March 16, 2011 Last Updated: October 1, 2021

    IMG_3711

    [Check out the review of the current vintage of this wine here: Kirkland Signature Rutherford Napa Valley Meritage 2011 - A Sure Thing!]

    Costco delivers another knockout Kirkland Signature wine.

    $13.99 at Costco.

    The first question that comes to my mind is what exactly is a "Meritage" anyway? Meritage is basically a Bordeaux blend that's not from France. As I understand it, since the non-French growers (primarily California) couldn't use the Bordeaux label for their blends they made up their own label following similar standards. To get the Meritage (pronounced like "heritage") label, a winemaker must belong to the association and adhere to their standards which include only using the traditional Bordeaux varieties. For red Meritage those include Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Petit Verdot, Malbec, and Carménère. How much of this is just marketing I'm not sure, but it certainly works for this wine.

    From the bottle:

    The Napa Valley, Rutherford AVA is known for its unique terroir of volcanic-influenced soil laced with gravel, sand, and loam. This classic Cabernet-dominated Meritage is 70% Cabernet Sauvignon, 15% Merlot, 12% Petit Verdot, and 3% Cabernet Franc from select Rutherford AVA vineyards. Drink now through 2014. 13.9% alcohol

    "The rich, ripe, black fruit notes of black cherry jam and cassis are layered with integrated oak spice notes. A ripe acidity follows a seamless thread through this multidimensional wine as it displays the inviting notes of classic 'Rutherford Dust.'" Winemakers Marco DiGiulio & Zach Long

    What's this? A wine that actually tastes exactly as the bottle describes? This may be a first, but it's true! We liked this wine a whole lot, with the cherry notes on the nose followed by a dry acidity and a great finish. Only 8,169 cases were made of this one so don't expect it to last long. Not quite a bulk buy due to the value rating, but if it lasts until our budget resets in April we'll be grabbing a couple more bottles for special occasions.

    [Edit June 2012: After another year in the bottle, this wine is even better so I'm changing my original Taste Rating of 8 to a 9, which makes this a Bulk Buy!]


    Taste Rating: 9              Cost Rating: 6
    Overall Rating: 8.3

    Recommended Buy


    1 Rating - Add Yours!

     
     
     
     
     

     

    i
     

    All ratings use a simple 10 point scale with 10 being the best. Find out more about my rating systemhere and check out the Interactive Wine Ranking to find all my reviews! You can sort by type of wine, cost, rating, etc. in the interactive spreadsheet.

    Filed Under: Bulk Buy, California, Costco, Kirkland Signature, Meritage

    << San Antonio Winery Tres Pinos Three Pines Cuvée - An Inexpensive Red Blend From Trader Joe's
    Caves do Salgueiral Douro Azul Portugal >>

    About Jon Thorsen

    Author and independent wine consumer helping millions of people find great wines without breaking the bank since 2011. Sign up for my FREE GUIDE to learn how! Read more about me...

    Reverse Wine Snob Insider Deals Header Square
    Limited Time offers with amazing discounts just for our readers.

    Don't Miss Out!

    About Reverse Wine Snob

    Wine doesn't have to be expensive to be good! Jon Thorsen is an independent wine consumer who has been helping millions of people find great wines without breaking the bank since 2011. If you're new to Reverse Wine Snob® sign up for my free guide and don't miss our exclusive Insider Deals! Read more about Reverse Wine Snob in the news and about me.

    Reverse Wine Snob Logo

    The "Perfect 10" Pack!

    Insider Deal Perfect 10 Pack!Four of our highest rated wines, all with 10 Taste Ratings (94+ points), all from different wineries, and all offered at a huge discount! Get them while you can.

    More Info

    Join over 450,000 followers on social media!

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

    Get Our Free Guide! How To Drink Great Wine...Without Breaking The Bank

    Free Guide! How To Drink Great Wine Without Breaking The BankReady to start drinking the best wine of your life, and save money doing it? Sign up for our 5 Day Free Guide!

    Learn More

    Helpful Links

    • - Ask The Expert Series
    • - Browse by Variety, Region, etc.
    • - Buy My Book on Amazon
    • - Get Our Free Guide
    • - How To Choose A Good Bottle of Wine
    • - Insider Deals
    • - Insider Deal FAQ
    • - Printable Lists of Recommended Wines
    • - Ten Tenets of Reverse Wine Snobbery
    • - The Rating System
    • - Wine Tasting Basics

    • - Advertise
    • - Contact Info
    • - Submit Samples for review

    How To Drink Great Wine...Without Breaking The Bank

    Tired of wasting money on bad wine? Sign up for our Free Guide!

    No commitments, no spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Best Of Lists!

      • - Aldi Wine
      • - Best Pizza Wines
      • - Best Red Wines of 2022
      • - Box Wines
      • - Cabernet Sauvignon
      • - Chardonnay
      • - Chianti
      • - Costco Wine
      • - French Wines
      • - Italian Wines
      • - Malbec
      • - Merlot
      • - Oregon Wines
      • - Organic Wines
      • - Pinot Noir
      • - Red Blends
      • - Rosé
      • - Riesling
      • - Sauvignon Blanc
      • - Spanish Wines
      • - Sparkling Wine
      • - Syrah
      • - Thanksgiving Wines
      • - Trader Joe's Wine
      • - Vegan Wines
      • - Zinfandel
      • And Many More Best of Lists

    Reverse Wine Snob®: Wine doesn't have to be expensive to be good.

    Copyright © 2011–2023 · Reverse Wine Snob, LLC. | Privacy, Editorial & Advertising Policy